Synthesis Matrix/Critical Appraisal 6-10
Author/Date
|
Aim of
Study
|
Type of
literature + type of method
|
Result
/Conclusion
|
Strengths +
limitations
|
Thematic
codings
|
Setting/
Context
|
Raven
Clabough
|
To show the
number of people dying from prescription drugs is higher than many other
illegal drugs
|
Theory
|
Teens that
suffered from depression, anxiety and other social disorders were more likely
to abuse prescription drugs that illegal drugs
|
This shows
through study that kids don’t consider it abusing drugs when its something that’s
legal. It shows that anything that is legal and easily accessible, kids
suffering from an disorder will most likely attempt to use. It limitation is
that it only compared prescription drugs to cocaine and heroine.
|
This falls
in line with many studies that have tried to prove prescription drugs and
their abuse when compared to illegal drugs.
|
This study
was done by counting the number of kids who used prescription drugs and out
of that number, how many were suffering from a social disorder.
|
John Gibb
|
To compare
how well alternative medicines work as apposed to prescription medication
|
Behaviors,
Attitudes
|
There wasn’t
a conclusion to this
|
The
strengths are that it backs the reasoning behind people looking for
alternative medicines. It claims that people know there are too many side
effects to prescription medication, however it does not say whether it
actually works as well or not.
|
This falls
in line with arguing for both sides in a way of giving both opinions to
provide the reader with both options but not choosing which one is right.
|
This is a
study done by giving the many peoples reasonings for choosing to use prescription
medication or alternative medicine.
|
Thomas
Sullivan
|
The aim to
show that alternative medicine has some legitimacy behind but it also shouldn’t
be used as a scam
|
Observational
|
The result
was that there isn’t enough behind alternative medicine to be used in
sureness
|
The strengths
of this is that it tells how in some cases alternative medicine has worked
well and.
It also
shows that it could be somewhat a marketing scheme as well and doesn’t have
enough proof behind it, The limitation is that this study says very little
for actual prescription medication to compare.
|
This
article is in general trying to tell that it could be tried but that
alternative medication shouldn’t be relied on just yet.
|
This was
done just by asking others who have studied this.
|
Dr. Mercola
|
To show
that you are way more likely to die from pharmaceutical drugs than natural
remidies or supplements.
|
Case
control
|
The result
was that you are 62,000 times more likely to die from pharmaceuticals that
supplements.
|
The strength
in this is they really did good studying on the numbers to show how dangerous
prescription drugs are when compared to other alternative remedies. They
however are obviously more proven to work though. The limitation is that they
don’t give any solution.
|
This
follows the same guideline that many articles do in that prescription drugs
are incredibly dangerous.
|
This was
done by taking Many studies and using 1 independent variable to test these to
see how much more dangerous prescription drugs are than alternatives.
|
To find out
whether patients know the effects of the drugs their taking
|
Case
control
|
The result
was that many o the patients taking these drugs did not know the toxic
effects it had on them
|
The
strength of this is that they did the testing and found that out of all the
users most did not know what it even was they were taking.
The limitation was that they provided no solution. |
This is a
type of test to see how patients react to the safety of the drugs they are
taking.
|
This was
done by taking a number of patients that had used an alternative medication
and finding out which number even knew what drugs were in it.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
No comments:
Post a Comment